Is Ectoin the New Niacinamide?

When it comes to trending skincare ingredients, ectoin isn’t exactly a household name. But recently, this ingredient has caught the attention of many clinical skincare brands. It has many interesting properties, particularly for skin barrier support and hydration. In fact, the early data has some people touting that this may just be the “new age niacinamide”. So let’s dive into what ectoin is, what it actually does for the skin, whether or not it can be thought of as a niacinamide replacement, and who should be adding this into their skincare routine.

What is Ectoin?

Ectoin is a type of amino acid found in extremophile bacteria — organisms that thrive in harsh environments. Ectoin in particular is considered to be an “osmolyte” This means that ectoin helps balance osmotic pressure, preventing cells from drying out or becoming damaged even in incredibly salty environments. Due to this osmotic pressure balancing property, ectoin is actually already used as an active ingredient in over-the-counter products like nasal sprays and eye drops. But what does it do for your skin?

What Does Ectoin Do for Skin?

Luckily for us! This is not one of those ingredients that became trendy without real clinical evidence behind it. In fact, ectoin has been tested for the following skin benefits:

• Protection Against UV Damage: In vitro studies suggest it may help shield skin from UV and other environmental stress. Studies have shown that skin cell cultures can better survive UV damage in the presence of ectoin. 

• Moisturizing & Barrier Support: helps boost hydration instantly, as well as increase skin’s own ability to retain moisture better over time. In fact, there is a clinical that showed that formulas as low as 2% can help skin recover immediately (over 10 hours) from dehydration compared to a placebo. Another study with 104 participants tested 2% Ectoin cream against a placebo, showing significant improvements in dry and sensitive skin over four weeks.  Even after stopping application, hydration levels remained higher than baseline, suggesting long-term barrier benefits.

• Soothing Properties: Helps calm sensitive or irritated skin. Higher level ectoin (5.5% to 7%) have been tested on individuals with atopic dermatitis and other skin conditions that compromise the skin barrier. Ectoin can help compromised skin barrier

Can Ectoin Compare to Niacinamide?

That all sounds fantastic, but does ectoin hold up against a skincare heavyweight like niacinamide?

This is sadly not an arena with a lot of data for us to dissect. There simply isn't a very definitive niacinamide vs. ectoin clinical study we can look at. We were able to find just one paltry study that showed at the same concentration, both ectoin and niacinamide can potentially decrease irritation caused by surfactants. 

What does that mean? Ultimately, comparing niacinamide with ectoin is like comparing apples to coconuts - it’s a bit weird. Niacinamide does have some barrier support data as well, but this is where the similarities end. Niacinamide is a jack-of-all-trades type active ingredient that also has sebum reduction, skin brightening, and pore reduction benefits on top of the barrier care effects. On the other hand, ectoin’s data is firmly in the soothing, moisturization, skin barrier care realm.

Does that mean niacinamide is better? We would say ectoin’s barrier care data is arguably even more interesting than niacinamide, while niacinamide wins out on the sheer range of skin benefits. 

Ectoin in Your Skincare Routine: Worth Seeking Out?

If you’re tempted to start Googling “best ectoin serum,” hold up! Unlike powerhouse ingredients like vitamin C or retinol, ectoin is more of a supporting active rather than a game-changer on its own. It can be especially helpful for those with dehydrated, compromised skin. But If you’re looking for more hard-hitting benefits like skin brightening and anti-aging, you might want to look elsewhere.

Some things to keep in mind:

• Ectoin can be found in a range of products, from hydrating gels to moisturizers.

• A concentration of ~2% seems to be the base target for effectiveness. For products that don’t disclose ectoin concentration, this means you definitely want to spot this within the top third of the ingredient list.

• It’s a great secondary active to pair with retinol, peptides, or ceramides for an extra layer of skin barrier support.

The Verdict: Is Ectoin a Must-Have?

Ectoin is an interesting ingredient with solid research on hydration and barrier support. However, it lacks the robust data of niacinamide or ceramides when it comes to overall skin health benefits. If you find it in a well-formulated product, it’s a nice bonus—but not necessarily a must-seek-out ingredient.

Have you tried Ectoin in your skincare routine? Let us know your thoughts!

Watch the Chemist Confessions Podcast

References

Cheng, W., An, Q., Zhang, J., Shi, X., Wang, C., Li, M., & Zhao, D. (2022). Protective effect of ectoin on UVA/H2O2-induced oxidative damage in human skin fibroblast cells. Applied Sciences, 12(17), 8531.

Graf, R., Anzali, S., Buenger, J., Pfluecker, F., & Driller, H. (2008). The multifunctional role of ectoine as a natural cell protectant. Clinics in dermatology, 26(4), 326-333.

Kauth, M., & Trusova, O. V. (2022). Topical ectoine application in children and adults to treat inflammatory diseases associated with an impaired skin barrier: a systematic review. Dermatology and therapy, 12(2), 295-313.

Peng, A., Yan, J., Wang, J., Qian, J., Qin, Y., Zhang, Y., & Zhang, T. (2024). Research on strategies for reducing the irritability of potassium cocoyl glycinate in cleansing. Journal of Dermatologic Science and Cosmetic Technology, 1(3), 100018.